Might be helpful to look up notes on the caste system on pg. 12 of your notebook!
Respond to question in 3-4 Sentence
Reply to ONE student 2-3 Sentences
Would you rather be apart of the caste system in India or the Feudal system in Japan? Explain why?
Might be helpful to look up notes on the caste system on pg. 12 of your notebook! Respond to question in 3-4 Sentence Reply to ONE student 2-3 Sentences
27 Comments
Emmanuel Z
12/19/2016 09:12:30 am
I would live in the feudal system in Japan because in India, what if reincarnation does not exist and you work your whole life doing some that you might not like. But then in Japan, you help each other.
Reply
Alexa D.
12/19/2016 09:14:58 am
I disagree because in the cast system you get to reincarnated and moved up or down depending on if you foolow or not. I think the cast system is more fair and equal.
Reply
jordan r
12/19/2016 09:18:32 am
i agree what if you mess up on accident and you have to start all over. the in japan your soul cant get lost into a animal if you mess up as a untouchable.
Reply
Anya Cooper
12/19/2016 09:23:57 am
I agree with Emmanuel. You have no idea if reincarnation even exists.
Reply
Romeo G
12/22/2016 06:53:34 am
I agree with Emmanuel because what if reincarnation doesn't exist. If your in feudal Japan you help each other
Reply
Alexa D.
12/19/2016 09:12:46 am
I would rather be in the cast system of India because of recarnation. Also if you do well in that cast you move up ( or down ). Also I think the cast system in India because it was fair and it's seems like the universe planned your life.
Reply
Nicole P
12/19/2016 09:18:32 am
I agree with Alexa, because if you follow your role, your next life will be better. Plus, it is a lot calmer in India because the class system keeps everything in order.
Reply
Delaney B
12/19/2016 09:24:31 am
I can agree with Alexa. You can get recarnated into a higher or lower level, but what if u try your best in that one life and go lower in the next. I think it would suck to be an untouchable and not have a "life".
Reply
Melle S.
12/19/2016 09:14:39 am
I would rather be apart of the Feudal System in japan then the caste system in India. Even if I were the lowest class I would still have wealth and food to survive on. Even though the lowest class is often not bothered, but they are not caste out like the untouchables in the Indian Caste System. So, even if you were the lowest class in japan or one of the lowest classed you would still have food and resources.
Reply
Emmanuel Z
12/19/2016 09:18:41 am
I agree since If you are rich, you could probably get a lot of things. In the caste system, you do something for your whole life, and if you were a untouchable, you would be shunned and not cared about.
Reply
Nicole P
12/19/2016 09:16:05 am
I would rather be apart of the Indian Class system because, as long as I followed my roll, my next life would be better. I would always be reborn into something better if I followed my role while in Japan's Feudal system I wouldn't. I would have a better chance of not being killed in India than Japan so, those are some of the reasons why I would rather be apart on India's class system than the Feudal system in Japan.
Reply
Delaney B
12/19/2016 09:19:50 am
I rather live in the feudal system. In feudalism you ether work or protect. In the system u help each other out and it seems more fare then the caste system.
Reply
Jack F
12/19/2016 09:19:57 am
I would want to be part of the Indian cast system because if I was in a bad class I could come back a better or worse. Even though you also go down till you turn to a bug and die but still. If you were in the Feudal system you coudent come back in reincarnation.
Reply
Luke P
12/19/2016 04:52:36 pm
I definitely agree with you Jack! In the caste system you can reincarnate to become something better than you were in the past. You could still become something as a bug, but at least you might have a better next life unlike the feudal system.
Reply
Anya Cooper
12/19/2016 09:21:55 am
I would rather live in feudal Japan because even if i was a merchant, i wouldn't have that bad of a life. Where as in the Indian caste system, if i was an untouchable, i could be killed by someone, no questions asked. I believe it would be better live in feudal Japan, then it would in India.
Reply
jordan r
12/19/2016 09:22:17 am
i would live in the feudal system because i wont be someone that cant even walk on the street during day.and they don't treat you so bad if you have low standers in japan.
Reply
Trenton M
12/19/2016 09:23:48 am
I would like to live in Japan's feudal system because of how the ideas and actions in it work such as the merchants being the lowest because they leech off of the working farmers rice and blacksmiths hard work in the forge. And how when you do something in your position you get something back in return for it so that its a win-win cenario.
Reply
Jasmine B
12/19/2016 09:26:48 am
I would rather be in the feudal system. I would do that because when you do something you get something back. Also because you can get tax money too.
Reply
Luke P
12/19/2016 04:49:06 pm
I would rather be apart of the Caste System in India. I think this because there is reincarnation. If I was born into a low class I could just do my assigned job, get a good karma, and then reincarnate and have a better next life. I would not have to worry about losing my honor as a samurai and committing suicide in the feudal system . I just think the Caste system is easier to live in the the Feudal System.
Reply
John M
12/20/2016 03:33:51 pm
I disagree because what id reincarnation is not real. It may but we don't know that. Also you are gaining more in the feudalism system then the Caste system.
Reply
Isabella h
12/25/2016 02:43:21 pm
I disagree because what if reincarnation is not real. If it's not real you did your job and got nothing out of it if you were at the bottom.
Reply
Ethan M
12/26/2016 07:22:33 am
I disagree with you Luke. If you are in the Caste your life could be miserable depending on which level of the caste you are on. It would be horrific.
Reply
John M
12/20/2016 03:37:52 pm
I would rather be in the feudalism system because what if reincarnation is not real. To my thinking you are gaining more things in the feudalism system.
Reply
Isabella H
12/21/2016 05:36:15 am
I would live in the Japanese Feudal pryamid because even though you might have a poor job you still get some stuff from other classes. In The caste system if reincarnation is not real you could of worked your full life as a peasant with no one liking you. Also in the Feudal pyramid if you are a peasant people still talk to you and don't shun you out unlike the caste system.
Reply
Romeo G
12/22/2016 06:55:34 am
I would live in feudalism in Japan. I would do this because I think that they were fair. Until peasants started to rebel.
Reply
Melle S
12/25/2016 09:59:12 am
Why do you think they were fair? was it the ruler who was fair or the people who were at the top of the system? Honestly I think they were really that fair considering that the people had to give the samurai all their crops even though they grew and harvested them. It all really depends on what you think is fair.
Reply
Ethan Mattison
12/26/2016 07:22:41 am
I think that I would much rather be in the feudal pyramid in Japan because I have the satisfaction of someone looking out for me. Not where I have to do one thing for the rest of my life. I would have the protection of the Japanese army.
Reply
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. Archives
May 2017
Categories |