Might be helpful to look up notes on the caste system on pg. 12 of your notebook!
Respond to question in 3-4 Sentence
Reply to ONE student 2-3 Sentences
Would you rather be apart of the caste system in India or the Feudal system in Japan? Explain why?
Might be helpful to look up notes on the caste system on pg. 12 of your notebook! Respond to question in 3-4 Sentence Reply to ONE student 2-3 Sentences
21 Comments
Nico M
12/19/2016 01:19:54 pm
I would rather be part of the caste system in India because all it would be a lot safer because everyone knows of karma and wants to move up a caste. Therefore everyone would be nice to each other and I would not have to worry about losing my honor as a samurai and committing seppiku. I could live a happy life as myself.
Reply
Zach P
12/19/2016 04:56:58 pm
I agree with you, Nico. It would be way better to be living in the caste system than the feudal system. I also agree how you said it would be safer because everyone knows about Karma and would want to move up a class. I think it is important how you considered seppiku and how you would have to commit suicide if you were dishonorable becasue that was an important part of the feudal system. If seppiku was not a thing, would you still pick the caste system?
Reply
Gabriela P
12/20/2016 09:23:38 am
I agree with Nico that it would overall be safer because you do not have to kill yourself. Also, I think one of the best reasons why you would like to be in the Caste System is because you eventually get to move up, which Nico also said.
Reply
Mariah S.
12/21/2016 02:16:49 pm
I agree with you Nico. If we did our jobs, we would be born into a better caste. Therefore most people would be kinder and more respectful of all of the things they have. Because then, they would be reborn into a better caste.
Reply
Makayla K
12/25/2016 11:13:14 am
I agree with you nico, 100%. i'd feel SO much safer.
Reply
Zach P
12/19/2016 04:51:47 pm
I would rather be part of the caste system in India. I would want to be part of the caste system because I would eventually get to move up if I did my job. Even though I would be stuck in the same caste until I die, but at least I would get to move up if I do my part. I would also rather be part of the caste system because if I lost my honor, I would have to commit suicide. Overall, I think being in the caste system would be way better than the feudal system because you will be able to move up caste's if you do your job and you won't have to commit suicide if you have been dishonorable.
Reply
Nico M
12/20/2016 09:17:29 am
I agree with you Zach I would not want to commit suicide if someone else died. Also in the caste system there is a chance you will be born into a high caste.
Reply
xavier martinez
12/20/2016 03:29:43 pm
I disagree I think all that karma crap is over all really stupid and samrie are to cool to pass up and plus Its and death that at the time was totally legit
Reply
Jenni H.
12/23/2016 04:41:35 pm
I agree because even though if you manage to live a life without being dishonorable, you won't move up. The system allows you to move up when you die, as in the pyramid you have to get there or be born into it.
Reply
Gavin M
12/20/2016 09:19:34 am
i think the caste system.because if i were to be a peasant, i would become a fricking ninja and assassinate the crud out of those samurai!
Reply
Gabriela P
12/20/2016 09:21:41 am
I would rather be a part of the Caste System in India because of a few reasons. The first reason is if I was good and did my job I would eventually be able to move up in the Caste System. I would also rather be in the Caste System because I would not have to worry about killing myself.
Reply
Victoria A.
12/21/2016 07:24:43 am
I agree with Gabriela because I like the idea of reincarnatin. I like how there is a idea with new life.
Reply
Sofia P.
12/20/2016 09:22:03 am
I would rather be in the caste system of India.Because it is a lot safer by nothing to do with killing and super less violent.That is why I chose the caste system in India.
Reply
Victoria A
12/20/2016 09:23:56 am
I would like to be part of the indian caste because the n you have a chance to move up after I die. Even though you have to wait for another life it is worth it. Overall, the indian caste is better because you don't have to kill your self if you loose your war.
Reply
xavier-martinez
12/20/2016 03:23:12 pm
a futile pyramid in japan cuz samurai are so cool and would want to be one to have respect and power weapons and cute tiny little bonzie trees.
Reply
Mariah S.
12/21/2016 02:11:28 pm
I would rather be apart of the caste system in India. Then, I and others would act our best since we would know about karma. If we acted out, we would be reborn into a lower class. And if we acted properly, we would be reborn into a higher class.
Reply
Jordan S.
12/24/2016 12:01:57 pm
I agree because everyone would be very well behaved because they all believe in karma. I also feel that it may be the same in Japan because you can work hard and go to another class in your next life. That may also effect your behavior because you will work extra hard to be born into a higher class.
Reply
Jenni H.
12/23/2016 04:37:49 pm
I would rather be a part of the caste system in Japan just for the safety and belief that I will have a better next life. It would be a shame to be an "untouchable" for an entire life but it is better than having to commit seppuku if I lose my honor. Eventually the next me would be in a higher class while as in the pyramid, you have to work in one life or be born into a life to have a higher value.
Reply
Jordan S.
12/24/2016 12:04:27 pm
I would rather be in a class system in India because it seems much safer. It is much more violent in Japan because you have to kill yourselve if you loose your honor. In India you are just moved down into another class in your next life. You can still live out your life and don't have to kill yourself.
Reply
Makayla K
12/25/2016 11:15:48 am
I'd be part of the indian one. you'd never move up if you were not honorable. if you lost your daimyo you'd have to kill yourself. There's a lot more reasonable reason but these are my top 2.
Reply
Carlos M
12/25/2016 01:42:39 pm
I would rather live in the Indain cast system. They bealive in karma som all the people will try to be good people. If I do good or do t I am sopposued to do I will go up in class.
Reply
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. Archives
May 2017
Categories |