3-4 Sentence Response
2-3 Sentence Reply
In your opinion, were European & Japanese feudal societies more similar or different from each other? Why?
3-4 Sentence Response 2-3 Sentence Reply
33 Comments
Anthony L
4/25/2016 01:28:09 pm
Different because Japan had more parts to the triangle than Europe. Also also samurai and knights were very different. That is why Japan and Europe are different.
Reply
Brandon P
4/25/2016 02:18:35 pm
I like your thought process, but I think they were similar. Knights and samurai were practically the same just with diffrent names of their attributes. Also, why do you think knights and samurai were different?
Reply
Sean Z.
4/26/2016 03:05:40 pm
I disagree with you, Anthony. I think that the knights and samurai are more similar. They obey Chivalry and Bushido.
Reply
Sean Z.
4/26/2016 03:03:53 pm
I think that the two feudal societies were more similar than different. They had land split up by daimyos and lords. They also had warriors like samurai and Knights. They also obeyed the shogun and the King.
Reply
Amy G
4/26/2016 04:44:56 pm
I agree with you. Sean. In my opinion, Both Feudal societies had various similarities and difference, but overall there were more similar pieces between them.
Reply
kevon s
4/27/2016 02:56:59 pm
yes I would have to agree with you Amy because they did have a lot of similarities through out the ways .
JadaJ
4/26/2016 05:03:12 pm
I agree with you Sean because they didn't really have that much difference between each other.They had a lot in common.
Reply
Armone L.
5/5/2016 07:21:10 pm
I agree with you Jada, because to me the only difference was religion and culture. Also, everything else was the same just the names were different.
paris r
4/27/2016 12:11:45 pm
I DISORDREE. that is because of religon and that makes over INFINITY simlarity.
Reply
Josh W.
5/1/2016 05:47:19 pm
I agree with you because they also did a you help me, i'll help you sort of thing.
Reply
JadaJ
4/26/2016 04:59:47 pm
I think they were similar because the only thing that was really different was the names, religion, and there dealt was different from Japan. They had a lot of similar things. Japan and Europe had a lot similar.
Reply
Amy G.
4/26/2016 05:36:21 pm
Between the two feudal societies, I believe that they possessed more correspondences within them. In other words, I think they had more similarities. Although the systems had different names, the definition of each class really defends my point. Samurai= warrior that has to protect the shogun (leader). Knight= warrior that mus protect the king (leader). Plus, both systems were created to protect their countries fro invaders.
Reply
Etta S
4/27/2016 07:07:26 pm
I totally agree with you. If the feudal pyramid is the same, then so must their society. Two classes in two different cultures had the same meaning. So, I think that they are more alike than different to agree with you.
Reply
Noemi R
5/1/2016 08:47:02 pm
I agree that there are more similarities than differences between these to societies. They really just had different people that basically did the same job. For example, like you said, knight=warrior. I really like that strong point you pointed out.
Reply
paris r
4/27/2016 12:09:03 pm
I think they are more different because of the religon. I beleive they are mostly different because of religon is because I am super involved in religon. So that is why they are compleatly different.
Reply
kevon s
4/27/2016 02:54:14 pm
well I would say their different just because the Japanese had way more classes than the European's did. And the classes were worded differently. also, that the only similarity they had was that the European's had bushido and the Japanese had seppuku and which they had the same meaning.
Reply
Etta S
4/27/2016 07:04:56 pm
They were more similar. I think this because they're pyramid is about the same. If a society is the same way, then they must be very similar.
Reply
Nathan H
4/28/2016 09:34:10 am
I think that their simerlar to each other, because they have almost the exact same government in feudal Japan And Feudal Europe. These two countries share A Leader who disstributed land to a lesser who hires people to protect that land and collect from those who live on that land. So I bellieve that these countries are almost the same.
Reply
Erica P.
4/30/2016 07:11:28 am
I agree with you Nathan. Their government for both European and Japanese are pretty much the same. Also, like Amy said the roles all have the same meaning for them like Knights = Samurai
Reply
Mr. Kaciuba
4/28/2016 09:51:54 am
There are definitely similarities and differences in each of the feudal societies but in my opinion they are more similar. They were both based on land and duty, both had warriors & lords, and both had a code of honor. One of the major differences is the role of the leader. And if you think the leader is important in this system, then maybe you might think these systems are more different than similar.
Reply
Mark
4/30/2016 05:50:58 am
I disagree with you their are more similaritys than differences because all in all they have way more simialaritys than differences. I can see where someone might think that it is more different than similar but it really isn't.
Reply
Mark
4/30/2016 05:47:39 am
I think that they are more similar than different because all of the things are the same with different names. Like for example the knight and the samuria both warriors just they have different names. All European feudalism is is a slightly changed copy of Japanese fuedalism.
Reply
Erica P.
4/30/2016 07:08:53 am
I think European and Japanese fuedalism are more similar because everything is the same except for the names. Knights are the Samuri. They are both warriors. Also, they both had the same definition like Knights and warriors both have to protect their leader
Reply
Lilli J
4/30/2016 06:57:15 pm
I agree with you Erica because they were pretty much the same.
Reply
william k
4/30/2016 06:01:59 pm
I think they were more similar. the reason why is because they had the same type of people at the same type of level. This means that they go from the largest amount of power to the lowest.
Reply
Alex .M
5/1/2016 05:55:39 pm
I agree with you Will, they were very similar. They had very similar honor codes and class systems. But, you should consider that they had different religions.
Reply
Lilli J.
4/30/2016 06:54:45 pm
I think they were more similar because they had pretty much the same thing exept they had different names, knights were the samuri they are both kinda the same.
Reply
Gustavo A
5/1/2016 06:54:49 pm
I agree with you lilli because the names were only the diffrent things they even had kings but not really power for japan but nothing else is diffrent just very minor things like names and codes of honor
Reply
Josh W.
5/1/2016 05:46:04 pm
I think they were more similar because they both had a code of honor. they also both did a you help me, i'll help sort of thing.
Reply
Alex .M
5/1/2016 05:47:02 pm
I think that they are more similar than different. I do because, the only real difference is, the religion that they worshipped. Plus, I think that one of the only other reasons they're different is, the weapons. Even the Honer code is almost identical.
Reply
Gustavo A
5/1/2016 06:49:11 pm
I think they were similar because they are both based on the same thing like land and who ruled land and who gave expect the names were diffrent and peasents were higher honor but nothing so big and kings and they also had the code of honor very similar like Chivalry and Bushido
Reply
Noemi R
5/1/2016 08:44:43 pm
In my opinion, feudalism was more similar in these two cultures. The religion was the only thing that was really different . Both systems were created to protect their country from enemies.
Reply
Armone L.
5/5/2016 07:16:57 pm
I think that they were more similar, because they both had a feudalism system and the classes just different names for some of them. They both also had code of honors just different names of those also. I think the only difference to me was the religion and culture
Reply
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. Archives
May 2017
Categories |