Might be helpful to look up notes on the caste system on pg. 12 of your notebook!
Respond to question in 3-4 Sentence
Reply to ONE student 2-3 Sentences
Would you rather be apart of the caste system in India or the Feudal system in Japan? Explain why?
Might be helpful to look up notes on the caste system on pg. 12 of your notebook! Respond to question in 3-4 Sentence Reply to ONE student 2-3 Sentences
19 Comments
Deniyah L:)
12/19/2016 12:13:31 pm
I would rather be in the feudal system in Japan.I would be in it because if you are a lower class citizen, your higher in the pyramid. I can be a peasants but higher than a merchant. Merchants are treated like scum, but, make a lot of money. sometimes even more than the shoguns.
Reply
Grace M.
12/19/2016 12:17:57 pm
I agree with you Deniyah. Merchants make more income than peasants. But peasants make provide everything that the other classes need.
Reply
Julian P.
12/23/2016 04:09:55 pm
I agree because any class you are in you are do not get disrespected. Mechants do make a lot of money as well!
Reply
Julian P.
12/23/2016 04:10:29 pm
*Merchants
Grace M.
12/19/2016 12:15:22 pm
I would rather be apart of the Feudal pyramid in Japan because in India untouchables are not treated with respect. Peasants were hire up in the pyramid than untouchables. Untouchables usually did the worst jobs as well.
Reply
Deniyah L:)
12/19/2016 12:18:05 pm
I agree. I would not like to be treated as the untouchables. Untouchables were treated even more poor than the merchants. at least merchants you can talk to, the untouchables you cant even talk to.
Reply
TaniyaM
12/23/2016 11:44:13 am
I agree with you because , untouchables are treated with No respect and they were just a huge outcaste.but at least in the Japanese feudal system the merchants got more respect than the untouchables in the caste system.
Reply
Logan H
12/24/2016 07:26:37 am
I agree with you Grace. The peasants and untouchables had similar jobs but the peasants got respect from their work that is different than the untouchables.
Reply
Alissia H.
12/19/2016 12:17:20 pm
I chose the feudal system in Japan. You would be higher in with the pyramid. you would make the most money with all of your work.
Reply
Tyler B.
12/19/2016 01:05:28 pm
What do you mean by "you would make the most money with all of your work." But yes the Fudael pyramid would be a lot better, you have the chance to switch classes, and be higher in classes.
Reply
TaniyaM
12/23/2016 11:40:10 am
I would rather be in the Japanese feudal system because , In the caste system , you are born into a group and hope you have good karma to move up to a higher class in your afterlife.but In Japanese feudal system you can be a lower class citizen your higher in the pyramid,If you were a peasant , you were valued more than the merchants because farming and fishing were more ideal than shop-keeping
Reply
Hannah P
12/25/2016 02:54:54 pm
I agree with you Tanya M because I picked Japan too. Also you talk about the ranks of the classmen and how it works good job.
Reply
Logan A.
12/25/2016 05:20:00 pm
I agree with you Taniya. I also think overall the feudal system would be better for all types of people and not have to rely on luck.
Reply
Julian P.
12/23/2016 04:13:38 pm
I would choose the feudal system in Japan because any class you are in you don't get disrespected as if you were a untouchable. Merchants also make a lot of money compared to Peasants. Merchants also every class makes the amount to survive except the peasants if they are not being under control.
Reply
Logan Hurley
12/24/2016 07:19:23 am
I would choose Feudalism over Caste. I would do this because you don't have to die to move up in a class. Such as you could be come a dimyo When you just were your average samurai.
Reply
Hannah P
12/25/2016 02:50:09 pm
I chose the Feudal system because you are born into your cast and you can be ether very rich or very pore. Also I picked feudal system because if reincarnation is not real I will not have a chance of being born in a bad life.
Reply
Logan A.
12/25/2016 05:16:33 pm
I would want to be in the Feudal system. I would choose the Feudal system because overall all the classes are ok except for the Merchant because of how much money you get and the peasant because if you were in the 3rd Takagawa dynasty because you had to steal food. Other wise I think it best for all people.
Reply
Mia C.
12/25/2016 06:07:52 pm
I agree with you logan. The poorest class in the fuedal system is not as bad as the poorest class in the cast system.
Reply
Mia C.
12/25/2016 06:04:52 pm
I would rather be part of the fuedal system in Japan. Even if you are the poorest you dont get treated like untachoubles get treated. In the fuedal system doesnt matter what class you are in you still get treated with more respect than than you would in the cast sytem.
Reply
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. Archives
May 2017
Categories |