Might be helpful to look up notes on the caste system on pg. 12 of your notebook!
Respond to question in 3-4 Sentence
Reply to ONE student 2-3 Sentences
Would you rather be apart of the caste system in India or the Feudal system in Japan? Explain why?
Might be helpful to look up notes on the caste system on pg. 12 of your notebook! Respond to question in 3-4 Sentence Reply to ONE student 2-3 Sentences
30 Comments
Zack T
12/19/2016 07:54:18 am
I would rather be in the caste system than the Feudal system because to me it feels like that system is more fair. Plus when you are born there is more places than the Feudal system so likely I would be in a good class. Finally, they believe in reincarnation so I could be in a better spot.
Reply
Andrew S
12/19/2016 07:57:37 am
I disagree with you Zack. I think the Japanese is more fair. The Indian you are born into that class and you can't change it till you die and get reincarnated. In the Japanese you are based off of skill and other stuff.
Reply
Liz W.
12/20/2016 03:27:09 pm
I disagree with you Zack. I think the caste system is really unfiair because if you don't have a lot of money you could be in the botom even though you are a great person.
Reply
Andrew S
12/19/2016 07:54:54 am
I would prefer the Japanese Feudalism system. I like the Japanese one better because they go off skill and other stuff. They don't go off money like the Indian Caste system.
Reply
Zack T
12/19/2016 07:58:19 am
I disagree Andrew because what if you do not want to be a samurai or your not skilled enough? You would probably have a bad life right?
Reply
Angie S.
12/19/2016 07:55:37 am
I would rather be part of the Feudal system in Japan because the Feudal system is more fair than the Caste system. The Feudal system is more fair because in the Caste system you could be an untouchable, and never be able to be anything else. In the Feudal system, they did not have an untouchable class that was as bad as the one in the Caste system. In the Feudal system, the lowest class was treated more fairly than the untouchables were.
Reply
Miles L.
12/20/2016 05:53:11 pm
I agree. If I were in the Caste System, I'd stay in the same caste my whole life. Where in japan, you can switch
Reply
Josie J.
12/25/2016 06:40:05 pm
I agree with you, Angie. I would also rather be in the Feudal System, because, like you, I feel that it is more fair than the Caste System. Also because you are not forced to be on the class that you were born into.
Reply
Jacob N.
12/19/2016 07:55:53 am
I would like to be in feudal Japan because it is cool. I would want to be a Shogun. Or a ninja.
Reply
Garrett
12/20/2016 06:36:40 pm
i agree with you jacob being a shogun or ninja would be cool. but what if you were a peasant that stole.
Reply
Kevin S.
12/19/2016 07:56:56 am
The Feudal pyramid because there is grosser things in the Caste and you don't have to stay in one part of the pyramid. Also we get land in the Feudal pyramid and in the feudal pyramid you cant be an untouchable.
Reply
Tommy T.
12/19/2016 07:59:03 am
I would rather be in the Feudal system in Japan. I would want this because there is more positions to be. You also sort of have a choice of what you want to do when you're older.
Reply
Liz W.
12/20/2016 03:24:42 pm
I would rather be in the Feudal system in Japan because it is not about how much money you have but how hard you work. I think it is more fair because in the caste system if you are the merchant you are higher than the people who work a lot harder than you. Also because you have a chose of what you want to be when you grow up.
Reply
Kim G
12/20/2016 04:05:23 pm
I agree with you Liz, I would definitely want to be in the feudal system than in the caste system. It is better because working hard is what matters and not how much money you have.
Reply
Kim G
12/20/2016 03:59:03 pm
I would rather be in the Japanese feudal system. One reason why I would rather be in the Japanese feudal system would be because i can be born in a family of peasants but i can become a samurai unlike in India if you are born an untouchable you will stay an untouchable.Another reason is because in japan peasants are more respected on the pyramid because the are higher on the pyramid than artisans and merchants
Reply
Kevin S.
12/20/2016 05:14:17 pm
I agree with you Kim G. because you can change your class. Also I like that you cant be an untouchable like in the Caste system.
Reply
.Connor W.
12/24/2016 07:41:36 pm
I also agree with you Kim. Japanese people could move through the system unlike in Indais's caste system.
Reply
Bella G
12/25/2016 07:25:53 am
I toatally agree with you! It is better to move in the fudelism primate then to not move in the Indian caste system
Reply
maddy S.
12/25/2016 02:09:30 pm
I agree with you because (yes) the peasents are more respected on the pyramid because there higher than the artisans and the merchants.
Reply
Amira U.
12/25/2016 09:42:13 pm
I agree with you Kim, because in the caste system you can't change what you do at all. Pluse peasents are more respected in the feudal system.
Reply
Garrett L
12/20/2016 06:35:12 pm
I would rather be part of the feudalism system because I would be able to move up in ranks. also I could be almost anything on the system. but i would not like to be a peasant that steals.
Reply
Elyse C.
12/22/2016 10:56:06 am
I see your point of view. If you read my comment, I am not sure what system I would want to be in. They both do not have good outcomes if you are a peasant or an outcasts.
Reply
Elyse C.
12/22/2016 10:48:07 am
I'm not sure what system I want to be in. In the feudalism in Japan if you are a peasant you could die from the samurai for stealing rice to survive. And in the case system you can't go up to the next caste when you are alive. So I am not sure what system I want to be in.
Reply
.Connor W.
12/24/2016 07:39:04 pm
I would much rather be in the Feudal system in Japan. The fact that you could move through castes is a very important reason. I also think it's crazy that peasants have a middle ranked part on the feudal pyramid. Ahead of the artisans and merchants. :D
Reply
Bella
12/25/2016 07:21:29 am
The Japanese, because you can move through the caste system. In India the caste is strict you can not move through the caste system.
Reply
macy o.
12/25/2016 09:55:18 am
I agree with Bella because you can not move you stay in one spot. I would not like it if I did one job for my life.
Reply
macy o.
12/25/2016 09:53:24 am
I would rather be apart of the feudal system because it is not as strict as the caste system. In the feudal system you can move from different classes. In the caste system you can not move around in your life except your afterlife.
Reply
maddy s.
12/25/2016 02:04:58 pm
I would rather be apart of the feudal systems because you can go to different classes. And in the caste system you cant move untill your afterlife.
Reply
Josie J.
12/25/2016 06:49:28 pm
I would rather be a part of the Feudal System, because I feel that it is more fair than the Caste System. If you are in India, and you are born in the bottom class, you are stuck there and not respected, while in Japan, if you are born into the lowest class, you have the option to move out, and if you don't, you will still be respected. Also because you have the option to move out. What if you were bad at what you were doing? In India, too bad. In Japan, you have the opportunity to stop, and do something else.
Reply
Amira U.
12/25/2016 09:39:13 pm
I would rather be a part of the feudalism in Japan because it's more fair. In the caste system if you are born into the bottom class you wouldn't be able to move out of that system. But in the feudal system you can change what you want to do like we can today.
Reply
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. Archives
May 2017
Categories |